Your Financial Plan

I work in a software company in Canada and my fiancé works in India. I am planning to migrate back to India. My fiancé wishes to buy a flat worth 40 lakh before our wedding and gift it to her parents. She will pay the EMI from her salary. Besides that, she will be helping her parents with a monthly sum of ₹15,000. Is it a good idea for her to buy the flat or is it more sensible for her to pay rent for her parents’ accommodation until the end of their lifetime?


Buying a house may seem a good idea if your fiancé’s parents are going to live for another 15-20 years. But this will put huge pressure on your family finances. Assume, she takes a home loan of ₹32 lakh at 8.8 per cent for 15 years; the total outgo will be ₹57.7 lakh. For the initial payment, say, she takes a personal loan of ₹8 lakh at 12 per cent interest for 48 months; the outflow will be about ₹10 lakh.On the whole, the outflow will be about ₹68 lakh.

If the property value increases at 8 per cent annually, the house value will be about ₹1.26 crore after 15 years. So, the net gain is about ₹60 lakh. Alternatively, if you pay rent and invest monthly in a portfolio earning 12 per cent return, it will grow to ₹1.02 crore after 15 years. This will give her great financial freedom. Besides, you should take into account that your wife may need to take job breaks for 3-6 months for parenthood. The burden during these periods will be heavy. Also, if there is a medical emergency for her parents, it could further stress your family finances.

Net-net, it seems more financially prudent for your fiancé to incur the rental expense for her parents than buy a house for them.

The writer is an investment advisor and founder of Send your queries to

Read the rest of this article by Signing up for Portfolio.It's completely free!

What You'll Get


This article is closed for comments.
Please Email the Editor